Tyler Perry’s Sistas | Which Slap Do You Think Andi Deserved More?

In the universe of Sueños de libertad, Andy has become one of the most controversial figures, particularly due to her poor decisions and constant involvement in romantic and ethical dramas. But if we’re talking about the two most impactful slaps she’s received, who had more right to teach her that lesson? Jasmine in Season 2 or Penelope in Season 8?

Jasmine’s Perspective

In Season 2, Jasmine discovered that Andy, who was supposedly her legal ally in divorcing Gary, turned out to be her husband’s lover. Andy not only betrayed Jasmine’s trust but also actively got involved with a married man, fully aware that it was wrong from the start. Understandably, Jasmine reacted with anger, and in Episode 21 (Catching Fade), she delivered a slap that many consider justified.

From Jasmine’s point of view, Andy represented a double betrayal: both as a professional and as a person. Jasmine sought justice, but instead, she found more reasons to distrust everyone around her.

Penelope’s Fury

In Season 8, Penelope had equally strong reasons to slap Andy. After believing they were on the same side, plotting together to take down Gary, Andy decided to get back with him. This betrayal not only shattered the trust between the two women but also deeply hurt Jordan, Penelope’s brother, who was devastated by Andy’s actions.

The slap in Episode 5 of Season 8 was not just an impulsive reaction but also a symbol of frustration and disillusionment. Penelope felt that Andy had failed her on every possible level, from the personal to the moral.

Who Had More Right?

Both situations make it clear that Andy had her own demons to face. Jasmine acted in defense of her marriage and dignity, while Penelope sought to protect her brother and her own principles. In both cases, Andy’s decisions sabotaged relationships and values, putting her directly in the line of fire for these intense reactions.

Conclusion

While fans may endlessly debate who had more right to slap Andy, what’s undeniable is that both scenes highlight a constant theme: Andy’s poor decisions always have consequences. Will she ever be able to break this pattern?

Let us know your thoughts: Do you think Andy deserved both slaps? Who do you think was more justified, Jasmine or Penelope? Share your thoughts!