Love Island’s India Reynolds finally reveals All Star she secretly fancied
Love Island star India Reynolds has finally confessed which All Star co-star she had the biggest crush on – but it’s far too late as she’s long been dumped from the villa.
The 34-year-old reality star first found fame on Love Island in 2019 as part of the cast of the fifth season of the show. But this month she returned to the villa as one of the contestants in the second season of the All Star spin-off.
But unfortunately for India, she suffered the indignity of being the first star to get dumped from the show after Tina Stinnes snatched Scott Thomas off her. But it seems Scott was never really India’s type on paper anyway as she has now confessed she had her eye on another contestant.
It has been a week since India was ditched from the Island and she’s made her way back to the UK. But her affections appear to be back in South Africa with 24-year-old Luca Bish – who she wishes she had told she had the hots for.
She told The Sun: “I think if Luca was a bit older, then maybe Luca. I did think he was really funny. He’s gorgeous, but he is very young.” Luca is currently coupled with season 11 contestant Grace Jackson – who is just two years older than the fisherman. India remarked: “I think Luca was struggling because obviously last time he went in, everyone was a similar age to him, so this time maybe it was a little bit harder for him.”
India previously shared her thoughts about the fact she was the first 2025 All Star to get the boot from the show. She said in a post-dumping interview: “As soon as Tina came in, she said she liked Scott. So I thought, I’m either going to be single or I’m going to be leaving.
“I just had a feeling. The way he relayed it to me, I felt like he maybe liked her as well. So I kind of knew it was coming.” She added: “If I’d have stayed in we probably would have got over it, but I wasn’t feeling that good about the situation.”
Three days after India left the villa the fellow Islanders were left stunned by a shock double dumping on the show. Season nine star Olivia Hawkins and season three icon Marcel Somerville were both sent packing after just 10 days in the villa.
Upon leaving the villa, Marcel told host Maya Jama: “I feel like we had a really good, compatible relationship.” And Olivia gushed: “I feel the last two days we got so close.”
Marcel previously said: “I thought that I’d completed love and found my happily ever after – but the universe had a different plan. Somehow every time my life’s at a crossroads, I’ve got the opportunity to do ‘Love Island’. So I thought, why not?”
Before her entry to the All Star villa, Olivia revealed what she learned from her first time in the Love Island mansion. She said: “[I learned] not to worry too much about what people think, to be myself and not over-analyse every little detail. Just live life and have fun.”
